Chicken Sandwich Sauce Recipe - The Herbeevore (2024)

One of the BEST Pantry Staple Sauce Recipes

This spicy chicken sandwich sauce recipe is a fantastic pantry-staple addition to your table! It uses almost all ingredients you would have in your dry pantry or cupboards – most of which you probably have on hand. Keeping a well-stocked pantry makes it easy to come up with delicious and tasty meals using a few staples you can rotate.

I made a list of myTop 125 Plant-Based Pantry Staplesthat always keep stocked. And you can check out all myfavorite pantry staple ingredients in my Amazon shop here. A versatile creamy sauce recipe you can make in minutes, and a perfect way to top your crispy chicken sandwiches.

5 Minute Sauces To Enjoy on Anything

This spicy mayo sauce is what I call an Easy Weeknight Recipe – which is on your table in under 30 minutes. These quick and simple recipes are perfect for those nights when you want am easy homecooked meal but don’t want to spend hours in the kitchen.

I have a wholesection of The Herbeevore dedicated to Easy Weeknight Meals, that are great for the whole family. From soups and stews, to pastas and proteins (and sauces!) – a quick meal can be on your table in no time.

This easy recipe isn’t just for chicken sandwiches. It’s great as a dip for French fries, drizzled over grilled chicken breast, or great to dip chicken nuggets into! It’s great with juicy chicken thighs or drumsticks too. It’s tastes a bit like chipotle mayo and buffalo sauce combined into one, a perfect balance of sweet and savory which is afavorite in our house!

What’s In This Homemade Chicken Sandwich Sauce Recipe?

I get fresh produce from my garden and from Misfits Market– they sell fantastic fruit, vegetables, & pantry staples at a discounted price. We get Misfit boxes every other week and love picking out favorite produce for delivery. Get $10 off your first box here!

• Classic Mayonnaise:I like to usethis classic mayoto keep this recipe plant-based, but you can use whatever mayo that you would normally use in recipes. You can also substitute sour cream, Greek yogurt, or if you don’t like mayonnaise.
• Honey:For a great touch of sweetness. I recommend trying a local farmers market to find the best honey in your area. Or else,this organic honeyis the next best thing.
• Dijon Mustard– for a really nice flavor and texture,this Dijon is a favorite in our pantry… I’d stay clear from yellow prepared mustard for this recipe.
• Smoked Paprika:give an additional depth of flavor to this dish.
• Red Chili Pepper Flakes:for a little heat! I like to add a few shakes to this recipe to give this dish a nice complex depth of flavor – or use cayenne pepper! This sauce has medium heat, not too spicy, but definitely has a kick.
• Tellicherry Peppercorns:Like the salt, it’s amazing the flavor difference you can get with really goodtellicherry black pepper. Amazon hasa generic brand tellicherry peppercornwhich is the same price is buying pre-ground, and has a million times more flavor… so I use these really greattellicherrypeppercorns, which I would definitely recommend.

​More Optional Add-Ins

While the recipe below is truly the perfect dipping sauce, you can add in or swap a few ingredients for match your taste!

• ​Hot Sauce – for a spicy kick!
• Pickle Juice – for a savory, briny flavor.
• Garlic Powder – which gives the sauce a great flavor.
• Lemon Juice or Lime juice – for extra tang! You could also use white vinegar or apple cider vinegar too.
• BBQ Sauce – for a sweet and smoky flavor, barbecue sauce is a great add in.
• Worcestershire sauce – for a salty, rich umami taste.

How Do I Make This Easy Sauce for Chicken Sandwiches?

1. Add all ingredients to a large mixing bowl. Stir until well combined, and the sauce is thick and creamy.
2. Alternatively, you could use a blender: blend on low and gradually work up to high speed until the sauce is creamy and well combined.
3. Add this sauce to you chicken sandwiches (I like adding it to both the top bun and the bottom bun!), burgers with grilled onions, loaded fries, or in between a grilled cheese sandwich. Enjoy!

More Easy Sauce Recipes You’ll Love!

Honey Garlic Sauce Without Soy Sauce Recipe (Low Sodium)

Mozzarella Alfredo Sauce Recipe (Vegetarian, Gluten Free)

Tahini Hollandaise Sauce Recipe (Vegan, Dairy Free)

Mint Chimichurri Recipe (No Parsley)

Cranberry Mayo Spread Recipe (Vegan, Gluten Free)

Share this Easy Chicken Sandwich Sauce Recipe

This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I may earn from qualifying purchases, at no additional cost to you. Thank you for supporting the brands that support The Herbeevore and our beehives!

About the Author: Kelly Jensen