Welcome to our article on comparing deer vs elk antlers for dogs. Just like a delicious bone served on a silver platter, elk and deer antlers offer a delectable and nutritious chewing experience for our furry friends. These antlers not only satisfy their chewing needs but also provide a range of advantages and differences that make them a popular choice among dog owners.
In this article, we will delve into the unique qualities of elk and deer antlers, exploring their advantages and differences. We’ll uncover which antler is best suited for different situations, whether it be an active chewer or a teething puppy.
Moreover, we will highlight the health benefits that these antlers bring, promoting better dental health, relieving teething pain, and even helping our four-legged companions manage stress and anxiety.
So, join us as we embark on this journey to discover the wonders of elk and deer antlers and find the perfect chew for your beloved canine companion.
Table of contents
Advantages and Differences
We find it important to consider the advantages and differences between elk and deer antlers when choosing a nutritious chew for our dogs. Elk shed each spring their antlers and these are collected organically.
One key difference is the size comparison between the two. Elk antlers are larger and heavier than deer antlers, making them more suitable for dogs that are strong chewers or have larger jaws. On the other hand, deer antlers are a better choice for puppies or dogs with smaller mouths, as they are smaller and easier to handle.
Another important factor to consider is chewing preferences. Elk antlers are softer and easier for dogs to chew on compared to deer antlers, making them a great option for dogs with sensitive teeth or weaker jaws. However, if you have an active chewer, deer antlers provide a more satisfying chewing experience.
Ultimately, personal preference plays a significant role in choosing between elk and deer antlers for our dogs.
Best for Different Situations
When it comes to puppies, deer antlers are the way to go. Their smaller size makes them easier for little mouths to handle, and they provide a satisfying chewing experience for those sharp baby teeth.
On the other hand, for older dogs with sensitive teeth and weaker jaws, elk antlers are a better choice. They’re softer and gentler on the teeth, making them suitable for senior dogs who may have dental issues.
Regardless of your dog’s age, both elk and deer antlers offer a nutritious chew that promotes dental health and provides mental stimulation. So, choose the antler that best suits your dog’s specific needs and let them enjoy the benefits of this long-lasting and natural chew.
Health Benefits
When considering the health benefits of deer vs elk antlers for dogs, it’s important to note that chewing antlers can improve dental health and provide mental stimulation for our furry friends.
Promoting dental hygiene, antlers are a natural way for dogs to remove tartar and plaque buildup, keeping their teeth clean and their breath fresh. Chewing on antlers also helps relieve teething pain in puppies, soothing their gums and providing a much-needed distraction. Not only does this promote healthy jaw development, but it also helps maintain jaw strength in older dogs.
Additionally, chewing antlers can help dogs deal with stress and anxiety, providing them with a calming activity.
With all these benefits, it’s no wonder that antlers are a popular and nutritious chew for dogs of all ages and sizes.
Elk Antlers
SaleBestseller No. 1
- Split Elk Antlers For Large Dogs – 2 or 4 pack of Split Elk 6” to 7” In Length Antler Chews Perfect for Large Sized Dogs. Keeps them entertained and busy for hours. Lasts longer than other natural chews.
- Healthy Rawhide Alternative Dog Bones: A Perfect Alternative to Rawhide Chews, Our Split Elk Antlers are hand cut exposing the tasty center marrow. With no Added Preservatives, or Chemicals making it the Perfect Healthy source of Calcium & minerals for your Dogs needs.
- Premium Dog Chews: Sourced from Premium Grade Naturally Shed Antlers, Each Antler is Hand Selected to ensure top quality color, weight & density making it the perfect chew for your pup!
$29.86 
Bestseller No. 2
Amazon Brand – Wag Split Elk Antler, Naturally Shed, Small (Best for Dogs under 15 lbs)
- Wild Sourced & Naturally Shed
- Packaged in the USA with North American Antlers
- Premium Grade A
$11.81
Bestseller No. 3
- Nature Gnaws USA Elk Antlers for Dogs
- Mixed Bag of Split and Whole Antlers
- Stimulation for Teething Puppy and Active Dogs
Bestseller No. 4
Amazon Brand – Wag Elk Antler – Whole – X-Large 9.5-10.5 inches (Best for Dogs over 45 lbs)
- Wild Sourced & Naturally Shed
- Packaged in the USA with North American Antlers
- Premium Grade A
$26.83
Bestseller No. 5
- ENGAGING CHEW EXPERIENCE – Ideal for dogs 20-45+ Ibs, our medium 5”+ elk antler match your dog’s chewing instincts, reducing boredom and promoting a healthy routine. Each of our dog antlers provide durable, satisfying engagement, keeping your dog entertained and mentally stimulated
- FOR ALL CANINE COMPANIONS – Whether you need elk antlers for dogs large size breeds, elk antlers for dogs medium size breeds, or elk antlers for small dogs, Devil Dog Pet Co. has you covered. Our products are designed to meet the chewing needs of every size and breed
- DENTAL HEALTH SUPPORT – Elk antlers naturally maintain oral health by reducing plaque and tartar build-up. This process strengthens teeth and gums and freshens breath, contributing to your pet’s overall dental well-being through regular chewing
$23.97
Deer Antlers
SaleBestseller No. 1
- Wild Sourced & Naturally Shed
- Packaged in the USA with North American Antlers
- Premium Grade A
$15.91
Bestseller No. 2
- Hand-Crafted and Ethically Sourced: The Perfect Small Antler Chew Bulk Pack: Each pack contains 6 deer antlers, 4 to 6 inches long. These natural antler chews are ideal for smaller-sized dogs and teething puppies that will keep your pup engaged for hours. Our deer antler dog chews are proudly crafted in Texas using naturally shed, hand-selected…
- Single Ingredient, All Natural Chews: Our commitment to all natural organic dog treats, ensures that every antler dog bone is a single-ingredient, all-natural chew that your pet will love. These antler chews are hand-selected for A grade quality and are long-lasting and durable, making them a great alternative to plastic chew toys
- A Must-Have for Your Dog’s Health & Chewing Instincts: Our dog chews are free of any added ingredients, preservatives, dyes, or harmful chemicals, making them a natural source of essential minerals like calcium, phosphorus, manganese, and zinc. They also promote healthy chewing habits and help keep your dog’s breath smelling great and jaws strong
$37.99
Bestseller No. 3
- Hand-Crafted and Ethically Sourced: The Perfect Medium Antler Chew Bulk Pack: Each pack contains 3 deer antlers, 5 to 6 inches long. These natural antler chews are ideal for medium-sized dogs and teething puppies and will keep your pup engaged for hours. Our deer antler dog chews are proudly crafted in Texas using naturally shed, ethically sourced,…
- Single Ingredient, All Natural Chews: Our commitment to using naturally shed antlers ensures that every antler dog bone is a single-ingredient, all-natural chew that your pet will love. These antler chews are hand-selected for A grade quality and are long-lasting and durable, making them a great alternative to other dog chew bones
- A Must-Have for Your Dog’s Health & Chewing Instincts: These dog chews are free of any added ingredients, preservatives, dyes, or harmful chemicals, making them a natural source of essential minerals like calcium, phosphorus, manganese, and zinc. They also promote healthy chewing habits, can help keep your dog’s breath smelling fresh and teeth…
$36.99
Bestseller No. 4
Prairie Dog Pet Products Deer Large Antler Treat, 8-9″
- NATURALLY SHED ANTLERS – Prairie Dog Antlers are hand harvested exclusively in the plains, forests and mountains of North America
- LOADED WITH NUTRIENTS – Not only will antlers give your dog chewing joy, they are loaded with beneficial minerals and nutrients calcium, phosphorus, manganese and zinc and collagen, lipids and glucosamine
- BUILDS AND MAINTAINS YOUR DOG’S BODY – Collagen: Good For Bones, Tendons, Ligaments, & Cartilage – Lipids: Essential For Growth & Development – Glucosamine: Good For Joints & Tissue – Phosphorus: Required For Bone & Teeth Formation, Aids In Kidney Function & Helps Manage Energy
$16.01
Bestseller No. 5
- You will receive at least 1 pound of premium Grade A antler pieces, at least 4 antler pieces, depending on size. Each antler piece will be 6″ or longer. There may be a mixture of whole and split antler. Great for your Medium and Large Size Dogs!
- Made and Sourced in the USA – You will receive only antlers from Mule and Whitetail Deer and/or Elk. We do not sell any Axis or Fallow Deer.
- Antler Chews are from Wild Deer Antlers – All Natural Pet Chews – No chemicals or added preservatives
$39.97
Frequently Asked Questions
How do elk and deer antlers compare in terms of taste for dogs?
Elk and deer antlers are both tasty chews for dogs. While taste preferences may vary, dogs generally enjoy the rich flavor of both elk and deer antlers.
Are there any risks associated with dogs chewing on elk or deer antlers?
Chewing on elk or deer antlers can have potential side effects for dogs. Risks associated with antler chewing include upset stomach, digestive issues, and the possibility of choking or swallowing large pieces.
Can chewing on antlers lead to dental problems in dogs?
Chewing on antlers can potentially lead to dental issues in dogs. The hardness of antlers can cause tooth fractures or wear, especially in aggressive chewers. It’s important to monitor your dog’s chewing habits and provide appropriate chew toys.
Do elk or deer antlers have any specific benefits for dogs with allergies?
Elk antler benefits for dogs with allergies include being hypoallergenic and less likely to cause allergic reactions compared to deer antlers. Deer antlers may still trigger allergies in some dogs due to their natural composition.
Are there any potential side effects of dogs chewing on antlers?
There are potential health risks associated with dogs chewing on antlers, such as broken teeth and digestive issues. It’s important to consider alternative chew options, like rubber toys or bones, to prevent these issues.
